From the journal

Illustration Licensing: What Publishers Should Know

By Hagood Coxe ·

Most misunderstandings between illustrators and publishers are not about the drawing. They are about what the publisher is allowed to do with it afterward. A clear license, agreed before work starts, prevents nearly all of them.

This is how licensing works from the illustrator's side of the table, written for editors, authors and production teams who commission science and natural history art. It is general information based on how the business usually works in the United States, not legal advice. For a specific contract, talk to your publisher's legal or rights department.

Is paying for an illustration the same as owning it?

No, and this is the most important point in the whole article. Under US copyright law, the person who creates an original image owns the copyright from the moment it is made. Commissioning the work and paying for it does not, by itself, transfer that copyright. A transfer of copyright has to be in writing and signed.

What a publisher normally receives instead is a license: written permission to use the image in specific ways. For most book and journal projects that is all you need, and it usually costs less than buying the copyright outright.

What does a license actually cover?

A good license answers a short list of questions. When I write a proposal, these are the points I want settled:

Color illustration of a Venus flytrap plant with several traps, some open and some closed, by Hagood Coxe
Venus flytrap (Dionaea muscipula). One image like this could appear in a textbook, its ebook, a teacher's slide deck and a later edition. Each of those uses belongs in the license.

Exclusive or non-exclusive?

A non-exclusive license lets you use the image while the illustrator remains free to license it to others. It suits images that are not tied to your brand, and it is the less expensive option.

An exclusive license means no one else may use the image in the area the license covers, which might be all media or only textbooks, for example. It makes sense when the image is central to your product or you do not want to see it in a competitor's book. Because it closes off other income for the illustrator, it is priced higher. Exclusivity can be limited by field or time, which often gives you the protection you need at a lower cost.

Can we just make it "work made for hire"?

Sometimes, but it is narrower than many people assume. In US law, work by an independent illustrator can be work made for hire only if two conditions are both met: the work falls into one of a short list of categories in the copyright statute (such as a contribution to a collective work, a supplementary work like illustrations for a book, an instructional text or an atlas), and both parties sign a written agreement saying it is work made for hire. If it applies, the publisher is treated as the author and owns the copyright from the start.

Illustrators generally charge considerably more for work made for hire or a full buyout, because they give up all future use of the image, including showing it in a portfolio unless the contract allows it. Before asking for it, check whether an exclusive license for the uses you actually need would do the same job.

What should we think about before the brief?

The cheapest time to license a use is at the start. Adding rights later is possible, but it means a new negotiation, sometimes under deadline pressure. Ask your team:

  1. Will there be later editions, and will the figures carry over?
  2. Are translations or co-editions with foreign publishers likely?
  3. Will the image appear in the ebook, on a companion website or in teaching slides?
  4. Might it be used on the cover or in marketing?
  5. Do you need exclusivity, and if so, in which markets and for how long?
  6. Will your designers need to relabel or adapt the art for other products?

Who owns the original artwork?

For traditional pieces, the physical drawing or painting is separate from the copyright. Unless the agreement says otherwise, I keep the original and supply high-resolution scans. If you or the author would like to own the original, perhaps to frame or to give as a gift, mention it in the brief and it can be priced into the agreement.

What about the references?

Scientific illustrators work from specimens, field sketches and many references, combining them rather than copying any single photograph. If an author supplies photographs or micrographs for me to work from, the agreement should confirm that the author has the right to share them for that purpose. It is a small clause that protects everyone.

Credit and portfolio use

A credit line in the book, usually in the figure caption or on the copyright page, is standard and costs nothing. Most illustrators also ask to show the finished work in their portfolio after publication. I do, and I am always happy to wait until the book is out.

Can we license something that already exists?

Often, yes. If a finished image in my gallery fits your project, ask whether it is available for the use you have in mind. Licensing an existing image is usually quicker than a new commission, although it will not be tailored to your text.

Rights are one of the main factors in a quote, alongside complexity, research and schedule. I explain the rest in How Much Does Scientific Illustration Cost? For how I work with books and journals day to day, see scientific illustration services for publishers, or send me your brief.